Tuesday, June 24, 2014

Commercial Reviews

1.     This is wholesome (HoneyMaid snacks): http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cBC-pRFt9OM
This was an advertisement created by HoneyMaid snacks on March 10, 2014. The original advertisement called,  “This is Wholesome” was a celebration of all families no matter the sexual orientation, race, gender or color. HoneyMaid took a stand with what they believe in. They knew when they aired the commercial that the ad was going to receive a lot of criticism.  The ad showed a gay couple and their child, as well as an interracial couple. The ad received hundreds of hate messages on social media sites across all platforms.  How HoneyMaid responded to the negative comments they received is what is truly powerful. HoneyMaid hired two artists to create a collage using the negative comments and turned them into a symbol of love. With all the positive messages they received after their response, over ten times as many, they added to the collage to show that the positive comments prevailed over the negative.  It was a very timely response by HoneyMaid, which can be one of the most powerful advertising tactics if done correctly. Although the commercial provides very little information about the actual snacks that honey maid is trying to sell, it shows that they aren’t afraid to make a stand.
We are beginning to see more and more companies begin to take a stand for what they believe in. Along with HoneyMaid, Cheerios and Swifter Sweeper have created similar commercials that received similar backlash. I think that it is a good thing that these big companies are starting to take a stand in what they believe in instead of just doing it for the money. That being said, It made me wonder whether or not HoneyMaid had already planned their response before airing the original commercial. The company knew that they were going to receive hate mail because this is such a controversial issue. Who’s to say that they didn’t already come up with the response before they even received the hate mail? Either way I think it was a great campaign and I think it deserved to win a Gold Lion at the festival.


2.     “Mistakes” New Zealand Traffic Authority http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bvLaTupw-hk

This advertisement was created by the New Zealand Traffic Authority to show drivers that other people on the roads make mistakes and it is important to drive the speed limit so that when others do make mistakes they don’t pay the ultimate price. This commercial tugs at the consumer’s emotions. Anyone that drives a car or has a child can put themselves in the position of either the father who made the mistake with the boy in the back seat or with the man who was driving a too fast. 
The advertiser uses very powerful images throughout the entire commercial. The first is when the driver pulls out thinking he has enough time and time suddenly freezes. He looks at the steering wheel as if he has no idea what he’s done. The first thing he does is check back to make sure his son is ok and then steps out of the car. The two men approach each other as everything around them is at a stand still. As the two men converse, the cars inch closer and closer together which hints that there is no way a collision can be avoided. The father begs the man for fear of his son’s life. As he turns away, he puts his hands on his head and winces at the thought of what is about to happen.  Once he gets back in the car he looks into his sons eyes. Any parent can relate to the feeling of helplessness the man feels when he realizes there is nothing else he can do.
Another very important element to this commercial is that there is no music. It is very powerful and raw because the silence adds a realistic feel to the commercial. I think that although this ad is very emotional, it is also very effective. Sometimes you need to see an advertisement like this to make people realize how dangerous driving a car really is and how quickly something like this can happen. The whole point of the video is to show drivers that this all could have been avoided if people would just slow down and avoid distractions when driving.     



3.     Marmite Rescue: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H3SjrX7nUu8

This is an advertisement for Marmite Jam created by adam&eveDDB Marmite’s new campaign is called, “Love it. Hate it. Just don’t forget it”. Personally I think the ad is very creative. The advertisement takes us into the homes of everyday people where a team of professionals whom resemble animal control are asking questions. After going through and inspecting each household they find a jar of Marmite in the back of the kitchen cupboard. They the proceed to take the Marmite from the home and relocate it to a shelter for Marmite where other loving families can pick up the jars and get good use out of it. The commercial attempts to mimic the relocation of neglected animals in a funny parody.
After doing some research on the commercial I discovered that it received over 250 complaints that the ad was in bad taste and is offensive. It is accused of being offensive towards animal welfare charities and child protection agencies.  Many complained on Facebook that the ad was in “poor taste” and “makes a mockery of animal rescue. The judges at The Cannes Lions awards seemed to think otherwise and awarded the campaign with two gold awards in the press and outdoor categories.
Personally I think that the ad was fantastic. It was very funny and I didn’t find it distasteful. I thought that Marmite did an excellent job taking a product that most people care nothing about and creating a campaign that people find amusing and will most like share with friends and family. I applaud them for their work and think they deserve the awards they won.



No comments:

Post a Comment